10 Things New York Goodwill Stores No Longer Accept

If you’ve ever spent time browsing a Goodwill store in New York, you already know you can find some absolutely unexpected things on those shelves.

One trip, there’s a practically untouched kitchen appliance still in the original box. Another time, it’s a half-melted candle, an old coffee mug with someone’s family vacation photos on it, and beauty products that look like they survived three separate bathroom cleanouts before finally being donated.

I’ve seen unopened bags of charcoal at my local Goodwill before, which my husband considered a personal blessing. I’ve also made one of my own questionable purchases: several half-used bags of kitty litter that I kept in my trunk during winter because I thought they’d help if I got stuck on icy New York roads. Instead, the tape broke, the bags exploded, and my trunk looked like a cat had been secretly renting it out behind my back.

New York Goodwill Stores Have Become Much More Strict

Over the years, Goodwill locations across New York State have tightened up their donation rules quite a bit.

A lot of people still assume you can drop off almost anything as long as it’s technically usable, but that’s really not the case anymore. Between state regulations, safety concerns, disposal costs, and limited storage space, many locations now refuse a surprisingly long list of items pretty consistently across the board.

In fact, there are some things you can pretty much count on New York Goodwill stores saying “no thanks” to these days.

Some Donations Create Bigger Problems Than People Realize

Most people donate with good intentions, but certain items create major issues once they arrive at a donation center.

Some products can’t legally be resold. Others are considered safety hazards. And some items simply take up too much room or cost too much money for stores to safely handle, clean, test, or dispose of.

That means what feels helpful during a garage cleanout can sometimes create extra work and added expenses for the nonprofit instead.

Get our free mobile app

These Are Some Items Many New York Goodwill Stores Commonly Refuse

While policies can still vary slightly from one location to another, New York donation centers have become far more selective than they used to be.

Before loading up the car for your next donation run, here are some of the items many Goodwill stores throughout New York no longer accept.